Nothing is too wonderful to be true!
San Diego | November 5, 2004 | Tracked
Cast: John Lithgow (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Broadway | Preview | January 31, 2005 | Untracked
Cast: Norbert Leo Butz (Freddie), John Lithegow (Lawrence) and Sherie Rene Scott (Christine).
Notes: First preview
Broadway | May 30, 2005 | Tracked
Cast: Sherie Rene Scott (Christine Colgate), Gregory Jbara (Andrè Thibault), John Lithgow (Lawrence Jameson), Joanna Gleason (Muriel Eubanks), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy Benson), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene Oakes)
Broadway | January 15, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: John Lithgow (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: John Lithgow's Final Performance
Broadway | March 7, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Rachel York (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Mylinda Hull (Jolene)
Broadway | June 18, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Rachel York (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: Rachel York's Final Performance
Broadway | July 16, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Sarah Gettlefinger (Jolene)
Notes: Jonathan Pryce and Norbet Leo Butz's Final Performances
Broadway | July 23, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Brian D'Arcy James (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Sarah Gettlefinger (Jolene)
Notes: Greg Jbara's Final Pefromance
Broadway | July 26, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Brian d'Arcy James (Freddy), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Julie Conners (u/s Christine), Dennis Parlato (u/s Andre), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
1NT | August 15, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Tom Hewitt (Lawrence Jameson), Timothy Gulan (Freddy Benson), Laura Marie Duncan (Christine Colgate), Hollis Resnik (Muriel Eubanks), Drew McVety (Andre Thibault), Jenifer Foote (Jolene Oakes)
Broadway | September 3, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Brian D'Arcy (Freddy), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Richard Kind (Andre), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: Closing Night Performance!
1NT | Providence, RI | March 2, 2007 | Tracked
Cast: Tom Hewitt (Lawrence), Todd Anderson (u/s Freddy), Laura Marie Duncan (Christine), Drew McVety (Andre), Kim Shriver (Muriel), Paige Pardy (Jolene)
2NT | Albuquerque, NM | January 17, 2009 | Matinee | FrogQueen's Master | Untracked
Cast: Brian McKay (Lawrence Jameson), Stephen Patterson (Freddy Benson), Heather McGuigan, Christy Adamson.
Notes: Cast guessed at from article written at the time of the tour.
London | July 24, 2014 | Matinee | cynicale's Master | Untracked
Cast: Darren Bennett (u/s Lawrence Jameson), Rufus Hound (Freddy Benson), Katherine Kingsley (Christine Colgate), Samantha Bond (Muriel Eubanks), John Marquez (Andre Thibault), Genevieve Nicole (u/s Jolene Oakes)
London | November 20, 2014 | Untracked
Cast: Robert Lindsay (Lawrence Jameson), Alex Gaumond (Freddy Benson), Katherine Kingsley (Christine Colgate), Bonnie Langford (Muriel Eubanks), Gary Wilmot (Andre Thibault), Lizzy Connolly (Jolene Oakes)
London Concert | November 24, 2024 | forfivemoreminutes' Master | Untracked
Cast: Hadley Fraser (Lawrence Jameson), Ramin Karimloo (Freddy Benson), Carly Mercedes Dyer (Christine Colgate), Janie Dee (Muriel Eubanks), Cameron Blakely (Inspector Andres), Alex Young (Jolene Oakes)
Notes: Ensemble provided by the Mountview choir
Stratford Festival | September 10, 2025 | heavenmustfeellikethis' Master | Untracked
Cast: Jonathan Goad (Lawrence Jameson), Freddy Benson (Liam Tobin), Shakura Dickson (Christine Colgate), Sara-Jeanne Hosie (Muriel Eubanks), Derek Kwan (Andre Thibault), Michele Shuster (Jolene Oakes), Eric Abel (Desk Clerk, Nikos, ensemble), Bonnie Jordan (U/s Renee, ensemble), Devon Michael Brown (Gerard, Sailor, ensemble), Jarret Cody (Conductor, ensemble), Christine Desjardins (ensemble), Henry Firmston (Bellhop, Sailor, ensemble), Aisha Jarvis (Usherette, ensemble), Kelsey LaCombe (Lenore, ensemble), Amanda Lundgren (Sophia, ensemble), Jordan Mah (Waiter On Train, ensemble), Jamie Murray (ensemble), Stephen Patterson (Hotel Manager, Butler, ensemble), Ali Powell (ensemble), Jason Sermonia (ensemble)
Cast: John Lithgow (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Broadway | Preview | January 31, 2005 | Untracked
Cast: Norbert Leo Butz (Freddie), John Lithegow (Lawrence) and Sherie Rene Scott (Christine).
Notes: First preview
Broadway | May 30, 2005 | Tracked
Cast: Sherie Rene Scott (Christine Colgate), Gregory Jbara (Andrè Thibault), John Lithgow (Lawrence Jameson), Joanna Gleason (Muriel Eubanks), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy Benson), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene Oakes)
Broadway | January 15, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: John Lithgow (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: John Lithgow's Final Performance
Broadway | March 7, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Rachel York (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Mylinda Hull (Jolene)
Broadway | June 18, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Rachel York (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Joanna Gleason (Muriel), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: Rachel York's Final Performance
Broadway | July 16, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Jonathan Pryce (Lawrence), Norbert Leo Butz (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Sarah Gettlefinger (Jolene)
Notes: Jonathan Pryce and Norbet Leo Butz's Final Performances
Broadway | July 23, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Brian D'Arcy James (Freddy), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Greg Jbara (Andre), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Sarah Gettlefinger (Jolene)
Notes: Greg Jbara's Final Pefromance
Broadway | July 26, 2006 | Untracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Brian d'Arcy James (Freddy), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Julie Conners (u/s Christine), Dennis Parlato (u/s Andre), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
1NT | August 15, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Tom Hewitt (Lawrence Jameson), Timothy Gulan (Freddy Benson), Laura Marie Duncan (Christine Colgate), Hollis Resnik (Muriel Eubanks), Drew McVety (Andre Thibault), Jenifer Foote (Jolene Oakes)
Broadway | September 3, 2006 | Tracked
Cast: Keith Carradine (Lawrence), Sherie Rene Scott (Christine), Brian D'Arcy (Freddy), Lucie Arnaz (Muriel), Richard Kind (Andre), Sara Gettelfinger (Jolene)
Notes: Closing Night Performance!
1NT | Providence, RI | March 2, 2007 | Tracked
Cast: Tom Hewitt (Lawrence), Todd Anderson (u/s Freddy), Laura Marie Duncan (Christine), Drew McVety (Andre), Kim Shriver (Muriel), Paige Pardy (Jolene)
2NT | Albuquerque, NM | January 17, 2009 | Matinee | FrogQueen's Master | Untracked
Cast: Brian McKay (Lawrence Jameson), Stephen Patterson (Freddy Benson), Heather McGuigan, Christy Adamson.
Notes: Cast guessed at from article written at the time of the tour.
London | July 24, 2014 | Matinee | cynicale's Master | Untracked
Cast: Darren Bennett (u/s Lawrence Jameson), Rufus Hound (Freddy Benson), Katherine Kingsley (Christine Colgate), Samantha Bond (Muriel Eubanks), John Marquez (Andre Thibault), Genevieve Nicole (u/s Jolene Oakes)
London | November 20, 2014 | Untracked
Cast: Robert Lindsay (Lawrence Jameson), Alex Gaumond (Freddy Benson), Katherine Kingsley (Christine Colgate), Bonnie Langford (Muriel Eubanks), Gary Wilmot (Andre Thibault), Lizzy Connolly (Jolene Oakes)
London Concert | November 24, 2024 | forfivemoreminutes' Master | Untracked
Cast: Hadley Fraser (Lawrence Jameson), Ramin Karimloo (Freddy Benson), Carly Mercedes Dyer (Christine Colgate), Janie Dee (Muriel Eubanks), Cameron Blakely (Inspector Andres), Alex Young (Jolene Oakes)
Notes: Ensemble provided by the Mountview choir
Stratford Festival | September 10, 2025 | heavenmustfeellikethis' Master | Untracked
Cast: Jonathan Goad (Lawrence Jameson), Freddy Benson (Liam Tobin), Shakura Dickson (Christine Colgate), Sara-Jeanne Hosie (Muriel Eubanks), Derek Kwan (Andre Thibault), Michele Shuster (Jolene Oakes), Eric Abel (Desk Clerk, Nikos, ensemble), Bonnie Jordan (U/s Renee, ensemble), Devon Michael Brown (Gerard, Sailor, ensemble), Jarret Cody (Conductor, ensemble), Christine Desjardins (ensemble), Henry Firmston (Bellhop, Sailor, ensemble), Aisha Jarvis (Usherette, ensemble), Kelsey LaCombe (Lenore, ensemble), Amanda Lundgren (Sophia, ensemble), Jordan Mah (Waiter On Train, ensemble), Jamie Murray (ensemble), Stephen Patterson (Hotel Manager, Butler, ensemble), Ali Powell (ensemble), Jason Sermonia (ensemble)
